Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Roslyn Ross's avatar

When was America great? And what does great mean? Great as a military power, sure, since the Second World War particularly where Americans rode on the blood-drenched back of war, but that does not make a country or its people great in any worthwhile sense.

The US has always had grinding levels of poverty and inequality, despite its huge wealth. Nothing great about any of that. Americans on average, have, and have had for a long time, the poorest quality of life of any developed nation. They have the lowest wages, worst worker rights and least benefits and the least social welfare support in the developed world. Nothing great about any of that.

Does he mean great in that mythical American way of being exceptional, superior, God's chosen, a Light Unto the World kind of great? Probably all of it and none of it.

They have wealth and huge natural resources but nothing great about that either. I suspect Americans see becoming great again as being a State where more people can have a decent quality of life and the chance of bettering themselves as did exist for periods in times past.

But is that what Trump means? I don't think Trump values military greatness but I suspect he values economic greatness which is really another form of military power and has always been used as such by the US.

In truth, Make America Great Again, is probably no more than a slippery political catch-phrase to draw in supporters. If Trump is smart he will find out what Americans think he means by MAGA and deliver.

Expand full comment
Lenny Cavallaro's avatar

Trump WILL accomplish several things. He will make himself and his family MUCH more wealthy (think at least ten to twenty billion dollars' worth!). He will entrench an oligarchy in power. He will appoint still more ideologue judges, reducing the chances of justice yet further. He will increase the national debt enormously, possibly triggering a default. He will reduce regulations, thereby enabling far more pollution and disruption to the balance of Nature, and he will do everything in his power to accelerate global warming.

I believe it was Pope Leo X who said, "“Since God has given us the papacy, now let us enjoy it.” Trump and his followers believe that his ascension to the Office he now befouls was similarly directed by the Almighty, and he has every (divine) right to enjoy it to the fullest. Moreover, thirty to forty million people believe he is infallible. Hmmm.... Welcome to the United Christo-fascist States of America.

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts