Discussion about this post

User's avatar
roger hawcroft's avatar

Yes, George, hypocrisy writ large is ubiquitous today.

It is so, not only from many in offices of high authority but, just as disturbingly and perhaps even more so, among the general populace.

Socialisation by parents, peers, schooling, media and religion have created a society where far too many are apparently no longer capable of exercising their intellect and are even too lazy to make the effort or take the time to ascertain the actual facts relating to events or the history and causes leading up to them.

The irrational prejudice against Islam or more precisely, 'Muslims' and the just but overly used sentiment of sympathy for Jews because of what happened to them under National Socialism, contribute in no small way to the warped and/or ignorant views of what is now happening in the Middle East and why it has happened. - We mustn't, of course, criticise Israel or even their 'leader' Netanyahu, (whose criminal trial is still pending having been delayed because of the conflict), because it is evidently antisemitic to do so.

Instead, we must listen to and agree with Netanyahu as he makes public statements claiming that the International Criminal Court, the International Court of Justice, the United Nations General Assembly, the Government of South Africa and anyone else who speaks out or takes action against the Genocidal activities of Israel or its blatant ignoring of international human rights law or the Genocide Convention, are speaking disgusting, wrongful, misguided and prejudiced nonsense against Israel.

Just a day or two ago I saw a televised statement by Netanyahu who, with a smirk on his face, hurled abusive accusations at Iran for one of their missiles having hit a hospital in Israel. According to Iran, the missile was aimed at a nearby military facility, not at the hospital. However, whether one believes that to be the case or not, Netanyahu was in no doubt and asserted that to target a hospital was the most despicable and appalling of acts.

If that is the case and it is probably one of the few statements of his with which I agree, then I have to ask myself why he approved and quite probably ordered the deliberate targeting, often multiple times, by both ground and air forces, virtually every hospital, school, university, police station or other significant public building or centre in Gaza and evidently considered it to be reasonable, presumably on the grounds, that the patients, children, aid workers, doctors, ambulance officers, police officers and such were attacking Israel and therefore it was necessary for 'self defence.'

That many of my neighbours, acquaintances and fellow citizens apparently swallow this type of tortured illogicality and absurd fallacy is driving me towards insanity of a different sort, i.e. complete despair at the state of humanity and obstinate ignorance and susceptibility to propaganda and manipulation that they lose all sense of reason, compassion or intellectual acuity.

It leaves me feeling that I should exit this life for the vista before me is one of insanity and horror that I am driven to a depression and despair too intense to carry. Yes, that does cause me to feel guilt because I am not starving and being shot at whilst attempting to get a bowl of food from an aid station to take back to my family, (or those left of it), who are waiting under a sheet of tin among the devastation and ruins of their homes.

Expand full comment
James Wilkes's avatar

What Israel has done to the Palestinians is - in their own words - a ‘shoah”, a holocaust. It means a catastrophe, a ruin, and that is exactly what they are hellbent on creating in the Middle-East. There simply aren’t words to describe or explain how far Israel has exceeded what most decent people would consider to be humanity. Genocidal is just too kind a word to use here as a descriptor. It is an unsuitable adjective. What they are doing now resembles an aspiration or ambition to commit atrocities. Why else would they continue an operation that slaughters innocent people and their harmless children who have barely a bag of flour to fight back with.

The West’s leadership has no excuse - none - for their cowardice and gutless, politically expedient inaction. They should forever hang their heads in shame. The Palestinians have endured 76 years of land dispossession and now thy are being dispossessed of their lives. The ‘Nakba’ or catastrophe in Arabic, refers to the ethnic cleansing of Palestine and the near-total destruction of Palestinian society in 1948, which is a long story, but it’s one that should be retold now because it showcases what Palestinians have had to deal with.

It’s NEVER the people, it’s ALWAYS those that rule, every single time. It’s the ‘regimes’ of whatever persuasion that seek war. We the people just want peace, hope, and a better future living alongside one another in caring communities.

And now, it’s Iran’s turn for an Israeli rinse and repeat. The Middle-East country that needs to be dispossessed is Israel.

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts