Discussion about this post

User's avatar
George Hazim's avatar

My pleasure Ethel

Expand full comment
Lenny Cavallaro's avatar

Your column invites an interesting historical parallel, which is also tinged with irony, since we are in the middle of Chanukah: << Israel’s strategy of decapitating Hezbollah’s leadership has always proven historically ineffective in dismantling the organisation. >>

How strange that they don't understand this, given their own history. During the rebellion against the Seleucids, Mattathias and all five of his sons lost their lives. When the patriarch died, his third son, Judah took control, but he was slain at the Battle of Elasa. Two others fell, before Jonathan and Simon founded the Hasmonean dynasty, and the latter pair were also killed as the struggle continued (Simon, treacherously, by his son-in-law). Ultimately, however, the Hasmoneans prevailed (with some help from Rome).

In other words, the death of a leader -- even the legendary Judah Maccabee -- did not end the uprising. Why do Netanyahu & Co. assume that the death of a Hezbollah leader will precipitate the destruction or implosion of that group?

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts